Is chromaticity shift a dealbreaker for LEDs?

Jan 04, 2021

Leave a message

LED-based lighting for general illumination was first introduced about 20 years ago. As LEDs became more and more prevalent, concerns began to develop about the magnitude of lumen and chromaticity shift, and at an even more basic level, how should these attributes be measured?

The Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) first published LM-80, Measuring Lumen Maintenance of LED Light Sources, in 2008, with an update in 2015 (IES Approved Method: Measuring Luminous Flux and Color Maintenance of LED Packages, Arrays and Modules) that provided for measurement of chromaticity shift in addition to lumen maintenance. The latest revision, LM-80-20, Approved Method: Measuring Luminous Flux and Color Maintenance of LED Packages, Arrays, and Modules, incorporates guidance for measuring radiant flux and photon flux in addition to luminous flux, primarily in response to the increasing market for LED-based horticultural lighting. All versions of the LM-80 standard require a minimum of 6,000 hours of LED package operation with lumen and chromaticity measurements recorded at least every 1,000 hours.

An additional concern within the lighting community involved methodology for projections of long-term lumen maintenance and chromaticity shift based on the limited data sets obtained during LM-80 testing. In response, the IES published TM-21, Technical Memorandum: Projecting Long Term Lumen Maintenance of LED Light Sources in 2011 with an update in 2019 to incorporate projections for radiant and photon flux projections and TM-35, Technical Memorandum: Projecting Long-term Chromaticity Coordinate Shift of LED Packages, Arrays, and Modules, also published in 2019.

Data collected using the methods of LM-80-08 and LM-80-15 form the basis of a DoE report authored by Lynn Davis and Monica Hansen, released in March of 2020, characterizing both lumen and chromaticity maintenance of LED packages as an update to a report published in 2015 that focused on lumen maintenance only. Four different LED package types used in general illumination applications were evaluated: ceramic-based, polymer-based, chip-on-board (COB), and chip-scale. A total of 223 LM-80 data sets, representing products from leading LED package manufacturers were used to project lumen maintenance and chromaticity shift per the protocols presented in TM-21-11 and TM-35-19, respectively.

Unsurprisingly, the results of the 2020 study demonstrate that LED package lifetimes for all package types have improved since the 2015 study (apart from chip-scale packages which were not included in the earlier study). In the 2015 study, approximately one third of LED package projected lifetimes were greater than 60,000 hours (L70). In the 2020 study, 96% of package projected L70 lifetimes exceeded 60,000 hours with the largest gains realized for polymer-based packages due, according to the report, to improvements in materials.

The main point of interest, however, lies in the area of projected chromaticity shift, which up until the publication of TM-35-19, was not addressed in any standard. This study used the chromaticity shift modes (CSMs) as defined in the table below to characterize the observed shift in chromaticity as tested per the LM-80-15 protocol.

table shows chromaticity shift modes of LED devicesCommon CSMs of LED devices and direction of chromaticity shift during steady state. Source: Understanding and Controlling Chromaticity Shift in LED Devices, RTI International. Used with permission.

Three of the four LED package types included in the 2020 study displayed chromaticity shift during the LM-80 test as shown in Figure 1. Chromaticity shift mode appears to be correlated to package type, apart from COB packages, for which no conclusions could be drawn. The study recommends further investigation of the mechanisms responsible for chromaticity shift in COB packages.

graph shows chromaticity shift by LED package type during LM-80 testFigure 1 Three of the four LED package types displayed chromaticity shift during the LM-80 test. Source: Lumen and Chromaticity Maintenance Behavior of Light-Emitting Diode (LED) Packages Based on LM-80 Data, US Department of Energy.

The methodology of TM-35-19 was then applied to project longer-term chromaticity shift and these results were compared to collected data in terms of magnitude and direction of projected shift. The study concluded that the TM-35 projections are reasonable and oftentimes conservative in terms of shift magnitude, but less than adequate in terms of shift direction. The implications of these findings are significant for higher-end environments such as museums, restaurants, retail stores, and even groceries, where the color of the lighting can impact how the lit objects appear.

From the discussion above, it appears that there is work still to be done within the LED community to develop better methods for assessing long-term chromaticity shift. It’s also important to keep in mind that the study results are based on data collected in controlled environments for LED packages only. Incorporation of packages into luminaires and operation of these luminaires in real-world environments introduce any number of variables, including losses due to inadequate thermal management, operation in harsh environments, and light loss due to UV and dirt accumulation that can impact both lumen maintenance and chromaticity shift and for which no assessment studies have been conducted to date.


Send Inquiry